Rabbi's Musings

What Does Judaism Say About Christianity?

Judaism and Christianity, as any siblings, have a lot in common. For instance: the Bible, words like “Amen” and “Hallelujah”, adherence to ethics, and prayer. Much more, really. Of course, we also part ways in important places. The Christian doctrines of the Trinity, Incarnation, Virgin Birth, and vicarious Atonement are foreign to us. We also don’t think that Jesus was more than a gifted teacher.

Sometimes I hear simple comparisons which are not accurate: “Judaism is about law; Christianity is about love.” Or, “Jews don’t believe in an afterlife; Christians do.” These generalities shortchange both religious faiths.

This time of year, it is interesting to note that both Judaism and Christianity share a collective pagan past. The holidays of Chanukah and Christmas are solstice festivals that celebrate light in a dark time. The night is dark because the day is short and –- when it comes to Chanukah anyway -- the moon is small. Likewise, in the spring, both Passover and Easter celebrate rebirth (from slavery and from damnation, respectively). Our master stories are different, but the messages are similar.

I have a great respect for Christianity and am pleased that the religion speaks to so many people. I am also glad that Judaism holds its own and is a great religion for those who believe in it.

After a very bumpy past it is nice to feel that we siblings have finally learned, by and large, to get along with each other. In this season of hope it gives me hope for us all.